Rally symbolic of a brewing class struggle

 

The mainstream mass media has been so busy blasting Thaksin Shinawatra for being the cause of all political evil that it has failed to see the seeds of the class struggle that have been germinating since the 2006 coup. Nevertheless, the attacks on the old elite have been unprecedented.

An SMS from the ever-reliable, pro-establishment news agency INN, that this writer subscribes to, warned yesterday that Deputy Prime Minister Suthep Thaugsuban is concerned about this talk of a "class war".

Discourse about class exploitation and unequal political voice has been growing among the red-shirt protesters, most of whom are dirt poor with little or no formal education. Well-to-do Bangkokians only have to see the welcome given by the capital's working class to their red-shirt counterparts to recognise this.


In front of Rama Hospital, red shirts' rally to the 11th Infantry Regiment on 15 March

Sure, they talk fondly about Thaksin and demand that Prime Minister Abhisit Vejjajiva step down, but many of their songs, grievances and angst is about class inequality as well as socio-economic and political disparity. The sense of injustice and inequality in Thai politics and society is real and has struck a chord with many in the Bangkok working and lower middle-class, who warmly welcomed the red shirts yesterday on Sukhumvit Road.


Red shirts' rally to Abhisit's House in Sukhumvit, 17 March (Photo by The Zombie, http://www.prachataiwebboard.com/webboard/id/29678)

The point is not whether the number of protesters is more or less than 100,000, because there are enough red-shirt sympathisers upcountry and in the slums of Bangkok. And judging by yesterday's motorcade the poor are a force to be reckoned with even if they are going to disperse in the next few days.

What will not disappear though is that, with or without Thaksin, there is growing recognition that the poor are oppressed and exploited, and their demands for greater socio-political and economic equality have gone unheeded by many in the mainstream mass media, which continues writing columns lambasting Thaksin.

Or perhaps they simply don't want to admit what they're seeing?


In front of Rama Hospital, 15 March

The level of disdain and bias among the educated middle-class and the elite, mostly in Bangkok, is appalling. They're not just ignorant about the plight of the poor, but are indifferent to it. In fact, they failed to realise the red shirts managed to shut down a good part of downtown Sukhumvit despite the mainstream media predicting the protesters had already lost the battle.

The level of real contact between the middle-class and the elite with the poor is mostly superficial and confined to relationships where the latter are servants and subordinates. The middle-class and elite feel that they are entitled to being superior and that the poor should know their place in life. Therefore, when the poor continue supporting Thaksin, many of the well-off folk in Bangkok have no problems supporting a military coup.

Nevertheless, nothing is as incoherent as the belief that only the educated middle-class and the elite are qualified to run this country. One must consider how backward Thailand remains politically and economically when compared to countries like South Korea to appreciate what a "marvellous job" the elite and the middle class have been doing for the Kingdom.

If the upper echelons of society have been screwing-up Thailand for the past many decades, might it not be fair for the poor to now say: "Enough is enough", and seek a chance to run or ruin this country too? 

Comments

good article.... thank you it

good article.... thank you

it is a class struggle

the elites: military generals active and retired and rich business vs the rest

NM has a report from a

NM has a report from a European(?) who thinks he detected a demonstration of the love the warm-hearted upper-middle-class Bangkokians have for their pi nong from Thailand.

Support for Reds from Bangkok at large

The atmosphere on the street was loud and energetic, something like a football game in Europe. Craziness, but totally awesome. Local residents and office workers poured out onto Phahonyothin and cheered on the protesters. Many thanked the protesters for their efforts, greeting them with a wai and/or touching their hands as they passed. Others handed out water to show their support. In an act of kindess from the protesters, at one point they presented a lone police officer, monitoring the situation, with a single rose.

Of course the Thai media won’t report any of this. They are more concerned with discrediting this protest with every chance they get.

There's a snap. Check it out.

A comment from a person who recognizes the neighb says that all the residents are off at work and those cheering are the maids, nannies, and service folk.

I know that this whole saga starting 19 September 2006 has educated me on the difference between Thailand and Bangkok. The sooner the Gulf rises up and washes Bangkok away the better, from my present perspective.

It is heartening to see the support ordinary Thais trapped in Bangkok do show for their pi nong, the Red Shirts.

I love Prachatai. Keep up

I love Prachatai. Keep up the good fight!

As someone from a countryside

As someone from a countryside farming rice in Surin, I disagree with your statement that seem to imply that red protestors from rural area were ignored because they have "unequal political voice." We all have our representatives. Don't we support to speak out our concerns to our SO-SO to do their job first?
If so, the question here is that do any of those SO-SO- make any voices to be heard in the parliament or...do they really represent their people?

During the 6 years under Thai Love Thai rules, we have never discussed about not having a voice. So why is it now that you believe these people have "unequal voice"? Or this is just the feeling from the losers when they are in the minority.

You must agree that we all are born with nothing. We have to work hard to get a better life. Those who are lucky are born in a wealthy families. But we cannot blame them for being rich.

With the question of the "Class War", I have never heard the rurals discuss their resentfuls to Bangkok people in this issue. The whole thing is more of a brainwash propaganda.

The question now is that are those people who come out to the streets to support the marchers really support their political agendas and viewpoints or they just want to show the support for their countrymen and women. I beleive in the later.

Agreed--to an extent. All

Agreed--to an extent. All classes need to be included in political discourse and not one class given all the power.

The fact that Thaksin gave hope to the poorer people of Thailand and brought them into the political discourse is the great mark he will leave behind on a sorely tarnished legacy.

My experience with Thai middle class people is that they are against Thaksin and the way he ran the country--not the class that supported him.

Thaksin subverted the constitution and the media; he was selective on allocating the countries resources for constituencies that voted for him and not the population as a whole. Most of my Thai middle-class friends are liberal and welcomed many of his socially progressive policies and were particularly keen to see the addition of the Thai working class to the political discourse, however, they could and would not tolerate Thaksin's abuses of power.

Thaksin won the hearts of the poor via short-term populist policies that often amounted to nothing more than handouts (not to mention outright handouts in terms of bribes at the polls) and did not do enough to bring about true, long term change that would be of genuine benefit the people he preached about helping.

The plight of the poor is a concern for many of the educated, liberal, Thai middle class. Their contention is not about class, it's about the style of leadership they support.

If the poor were to support a more even-handed, more fair, less corrupt leader, they might find they have a lot more middle ground with the middle class.

I agree. I believe that some

I agree.

I believe that some of the people to be blamed for all the political problems in the past 8 years are the representative -SO-SO, specially those who represent ESAN poor people. If there is any problem of how much political power the poor have , these people are the one who need to speak up for them. Majority of the SO-SO from the Provinces are also those who grow up in the city and from a somewhat wealthy people. They only see the poor as a valuable people during election campaign.

Just to give some example what I have learned about people in my village. Although, now I have a much better life and more of economy power than my people in a small village in Surin, I have never discussed or bragged about myself to them. When visiting my village, I tried to talk and listen to them by having small seminars on many many issues relating to their well being and living. Most of the time they don't seem to understand in many logical explainations. Part of it because of their education background, lifstyle, and cultures.

I applaud Taksin admin. in many policies that brought to the villages. Many were good but many of them were flopped and corrupted.

When Taksin came up with a 1 million baht per village and all other programs that tried to help the farmers including forgiving debt, they all were so happy and felt like heaven. Here is the problem; for example In my village, 90% of the families who borrowed at least 10,000 baht at 6% interest 7 years ago, now aday, they still owe the same amount to the million dollar program plus another 15,000 baht to the middleman at 20% interest. Due to their poor financial mngt skills and no advices, they cannot pay off their debts.

The reason is that at the end of the year, they don't make enough income to pay off debts so they borrow the middleman who ask for 20% interest in 10 days. They borrow 15,000 bath, pay off the 10,000 bath plus 6% interest and keep 5000 bath for a living. And 10 days later, they will borrow 15,000 baht from the 1million baht project and pay off the middleman plus 20% interest. It's been going on in circle since then.

People who benefit from all the programs are those few people who run as financial committees. Corruption becomes a norm in all Thai societies and if we cannot change this, Thailand is not going anywhere. Any Governtment admin. needs to address this problem.

Do I so wish this was true

Do I so wish this was true John, you must have good friends!! Unfortunately, it is not what I have experienced ... but if they exist, then the forces for democracy and justice must find a way to address them so they come on board ...

Of course, what the Thai

Of course, what the Thai middle class or any other class think or vote for is relative to the infomation that is available to them,and how it is relayed.Had the infomation in the recent Economist article,or Asia Sentinels "How Thailands Royals Manage to own All the Good Stuff" been readily available at the time of the Temasek-Holdings/Shincorp deals perhaps they might have had a different opinions.

"Discourse about class

"Discourse about class exploitation and unequal political voice has been growing among the red-shirt protesters, most of whom are dirt poor with little or no formal education."

Oh, that old chestnut again. Makes me think there is a shortcut key on the Nation's computer system to insert this in the text.