Is this transparency?
Blogger and freelance financial analyst Sarinee Achavanuntakul has made some observations about the Crown Property Bureau’s recently released 2011 annual report.
The Financial Highlights section of the report, on page 13, says:
‘The CPB’s total revenue in 2011 is derived from three main sources, rental income and dividend income from Siam Commercial Bank Public Company Limited and Siam Cement Public Company Limited.
The rental income totalled 2,700 million baht. Only 7% of the Bureau’s total property holdings in terms of area are devoted to commercial real estate development. The rest consists of land or buildings that are rented to government agencies, state enterprises and associations/foundations as well as medium-to-low-income residential and commercial tenants.
The CPB is financially sound, made possible by stable and continuous revenue yields from its three sources of income. It is confident that it will be able to meet with any instability or changes that may occur in the future.’
In her post on the investigative news website Thaipublica, Sarinee says that despite the CPB’s claim to hold ‘accountability’ as one among its core values, it chooses to reveal only one of its main sources of income in the annual report.
‘Official’ information about the CPB’s financial situation and properties can be found only in the book ‘King Bhumibol Adulyadej: A Life's Work’, which was produced under the supervision of former Prime Minister Ananda Panyarachun, and has yet to be translated into Thai, she says.
According to the book, as of 2005, the CPB held stocks and properties worth US$33 billion, and owned about 8,400 rai of land in Bangkok and 25,000 rai in the provinces, for which it had over 40,000 rental contracts with about 17,000 in Bangkok. The book also states that ‘the value of the crown property is considerable, but putting an exact figure on it is difficult.’
Neither the book nor the 2011 annual report mention the Kempinski Hotels and Resorts chain which is owned by the CPB, and the report only focuses on the CPB’s conservation and community development work and the royal projects, she says.
In contrast, the Crown Estate in the UK submits to Parliament its annual report which contains exact figures for its sources of income, and which is publicly available on its website, she says.
Sarinee ends her post by quoting the CPB Director-General Dr. Chirayu Isarangkun Na Ayuthaya as saying in the book, 'Excessive curiosity can also lower a dignified and trusting relationship. The increasing interest in the CPB in today's world makes me seriously think all the time about this appropriate balance.'




Comments
As well, the "King's Bank",
As well, the "King's Bank", Siam Commercial, is one of the Gang of 5 - the EGAT, Siam Commercial Bank, Krung Thai Bank, Bangkok Bank, and Kasikorn Bank - trying to Kill Mae Nam Kong.
The EGAT is behind the Xayaburi Dam across the Mae Nam Kong in Lao and - since neither the World Bank nor the Asian Development Bank will touch this crime with a ten foot pole - the four Thai banks are financing it.
So far the Lao's have lied, saying they are abiding by the decision taken by the Mekong River Commission to put off all dam construction across Mae Nam Kong until a real investigation of the environmental impact of such an undertaking is completed.
But a video taken in June by Living River Siam
shows construction of the dam underway and a more recent photo printed by the Bangkok Post
shows a gravel dike built halfway across the channel already.
The Phnom Penh Post reports today that
Bravo Living River Siam! Bravo Teerapong! It's good to see someone standing up against the Gang of 5 and their shameless crime against not 'just' humanity but against Mae Nam Kong and against life itself!
This dam is a fraud, an unecessary and costly sham! See the excellent report by Chuenchom Sangarasri Greacen and Chris Greacen, for an idea of the complete bankruptcy of EGAT management and the very simple measures that could correct, what I would add, amounts to their mis-/malfeasance.
They need and deserve all of our constant and very vocal support!
Siam Commercial Bank was also
Siam Commercial Bank was also apparently a major facilitator of the notorious
Shincorp-Temasek deal