Amphon's death challenges both red shirts and the govt

The death of lese majeste detainee Amphon "Akong" Tangnoppakul, also known as "Uncle SMS", inside Bangkok Remand Prison Hospital on Monday has re-ignited hopes of amending the draconian lese majeste law.

Some 300 people attended the controversial placing of his body in front of the Bangkok Criminal Court on Wednesday and vented their anger against the law they perceived as an obstacle preventing them from attaining a basic right to freedom of expression.

Well-known red-shirt writer Wat Wayangoon asked the gathering if Thais were not being treated like humans when it came to freedom of expression about anything critical of the monarchy.

At the same venue, red-shirt Pheu Thai MP Jaruphan Kuldiloke talked about legally protected rights in England and how Thailand has yet to achieve anything similar. And political scientist Paungthong Pawakapan, a key member of the Public Campaign Committee to Amend the lese majeste law, announced in front of Amphon's body that enough signatures had been collected to push the proposed amendment before Parliament.

It must not be forgotten, however, that Prime Minister Yingluck Shinawatra has insisted repeatedly her administration will not touch the lese majeste law.

Even Jaruphan was soft, almost apologetic on Wednesday, in front of the crowd of angry mourners wondering why this government was not doing anything - meekly suggesting they should try again to convince government MPs.

It's no secret a large percentage of the red-shirt movement is opposed to the draconian law, ever since the military coup on September 19, 2006, which ousted Thaksin Shinawatra. Many Thaksin supporters who subsequently became red shirts question the role of Privy Council President General Prem Tinsulanond in the coup, and more.

In private conversations, some-red shirt leaders try to defend Yingluck's position that the government won't touch the law - saying the government can't start a war on too many fronts, or by saying the government doesn't really have the power to push for such change and it could risk a military coup by insisting on it.

In public,however, there's a visible attempt to forge a truce between the old and new elites as well.

Nevertheless, yesterday, the red-shirt movement, the Democratic Alliance Against Dictatorship, sponsored the first night of the funeral rite for Amphon at Wat Dan Samrong in Samut Prakarn province. And at least two key red-shirt members, Somyos Prueksakasemsuk and Surachai Sae-Dan, remain in prison under the lese majeste law.

The continued vocal opposition to the law by a small but significant and active section of the red-shirt movement could be used by the Yingluck administration to remind the established elites that some form of accommodation might be needed.

But if the government will not touch the law, the loyalty of progressive red shirts to Yingluck (and Thaksin) - and the loyalty of Yingluck and Thaksin to these red shirts - will be severely tested.

The government cannot indefinitely buy time and expect no backlash or a meltdown in trust and expectation among the so-called progressive reds who oppose the law.

If no progress is seen in the near future, the time will come when these progressive red shirts must choose whether to continue to accommodate a government which does nothing to make the law less draconian.

Many reds will face the question whether they continue to support a government that allowed to Amphon die under their watch, a government privately telling them it would have loved to do more but just simply couldn't afford to.

With prisoners of conscience like Somyos and Surachai still in jail and the Public Campaign to Amend the law seemingly ready, that time is approaching sooner than later. And if the death of Amphon cannot make a difference, nothing will.

Comments

"If no progress is seen in

"If no progress is seen in the near future, the time will come when these progressive red shirts must choose whether to continue to accommodate a government which does nothing to make the law less draconian."

Yes, I think you're probably right, but it isn't just about 112, this government has abrogated its responsibility to make Thailand more democratic and law-abiding, and has instead established accommodations for the amartya in the fond but futile hope that they will benefit from it. They won't.

Forget JFL' s hysteria and froth and bubble, forget Tony Cartalucci's moronic conspiracist and monarchist beliefs, the Yingluck government is on the verge of re-establishing Thaksin's 'business as usual' when they welcome the 111 ex TRT people, many of whom established new benchmarks for corruption in Thailand when they were in power before. Including (almost unbelievably) Newin Chidchob, probably the most unsavoury person ever to darken the corridors of Thai power bar none. Probably even worse than he gangster Chalerm. Unbelievable.

The stark choice facing the Red Shirts now is whether to bring down the government they helped to elect, or to allow them and the old cliques to destroy the Red Shirts with the death of a thousand cuts. I have no doubt whatever that this is what is being engineered as we speak.

Rip it down and start again but be smarter, that's the only thing that's going to work in Thailand. Jack's house must be burned down and a new house built. Big job but not impossible given courage and determination - the opportunity which is available now has not occurred previously, and probably won't occur again. And make no mistake, if they do not rip it down it will rip them down because the amartya, if they prevail this time, will not allow the reds to accumulate power again - this is what the brutish Abhisit and Suthep were aiming for in 2010 under direction of the hia.

Thai-style democracy? Thailand is a 3rd world country with 3rd world people and a 3rd world education. And a seriously 3rd-world culture imposed and enforced to keep the people in line by 1st world rich people. This has to change - by force if necessary for democracy in Thailand to have any chance at all.

Prosecutions continue under

Prosecutions continue under Thailand’s anti-democratic lese majeste laws

Yingluck, her brother Thaksin and their ruling Puea Thai party are just as fearful of widening popular opposition to the monarchy and the state apparatus as their rivals in the political establishment. In the midst of the 2010 protests, the “red shirt” movement of the urban and rural poor went beyond Puea Thai’s demand for early elections and began to voice concerns about social inequality and the political dominance of the country’s traditional elites ... The ruling class as a whole has come together to prosecute cases under the reactionary lese majeste laws as one means of menacing anyone who calls into question the existing state apparatus ...

Puea Thai failing red shirts II

The elite, whether royalist or plain garden variety, now faces a challenge that it created. As we have long pointed out, the elite is most fundamentally threatened when there is a politicization and mobilization of the unruly masses.

While the royalist elite co-operated with the People’s Alliance for Democracy against Thaksin and the red shirts, the relationship was neither natural nor normal. The same may be said for the relationship between those congregating around Thaksin. He co-operated with the red shirts, but this is not anatural political relationship.

For the elite, both the yellow shirts and the red shirts are really very scary.

It seems that reconciliation is fundamentally about reconciling elite factions and demobilizing the scary masses.

PPT wonders if the red shirts can be easily demobilized or whether they can develop further as a political force. If the red shirts can’t develop further, then the royalist elite has a victory that a few short months ago would have seemed unlikely without substantial bloodshed. In essence, Puea Thai and Thaksin will have delivered victory to the royalists if they can depoliticize the red shirts.

The enemy of your enemy is not really your friend. When the 'enemies' patch it up ... they notice that in fact you are their common enemy.

The people have only enemies, no friends, among the 'elite'.

Peua Thai = the UDD. PT MP's

Peua Thai = the UDD. PT MP's literally lead the UDD, and each rally is built up around a cult-like worship of Thaksin complete with Kim Jong Ill style portraits of him on stage - that is - when the stage isn't built up around a Jumbotron to host a call in from "Dear Leader" himself.

The LM charade is simply to create division and undermine the Monarchy - PT won't put an end to it because they want to escalate it as much as possible. Their own propagandists, like Somyot, when not advocating acts of violence and sedition, have made it clear they seek to rid Thailand entirely of its indigenous institutions and replace them with the cult of Thaksin.

Finally - it is not "undemocratic" to send people to jail for making death threats - its common sense. If you can't call criminals "criminals" simply because they are part of your own nihilistic movement - you undermine your own legitimacy and the very principles of freedom.

Aren't you confusing Thaksin

Aren't you confusing Thaksin with your own boss, Tony? The "Dear Leader" is the one who pays YOU, right? Far too much in my opinion, considering you only ever produce political pap instead of hard facts.

Admit it, Tony. You're a journalistic yobbo with an axe to grind against good people, because of your own failure to cut a proper journalistic career for yourself.

Get back to the sewer you rat!

Within Laws 112 - there is

Within Laws 112 - there is certain articles which are too dangerous to touch hiding
and also this government still meet with the accusement of anti-royalists ..
so that PM Yingluck insisted she won't touch Laws 112 ..

Everytime Pravit calls Somyos

Everytime Pravit calls Somyos - Thaksin's paid propagandist, who regularly featured death threats, calls for violence, and even listed judges names, addresses, and phone numbers to intimidate them ahead of rulings against his paymaster Thaksin - he buries whatever is left of his legitimacy.

http://2bangkok.com/10-RedPublications1002b.shtml

some_text

some_text

And when Somyos supplied his violent, impressionable, purposefully incited followers this information regarding the judges, he didn't just put them in danger - but their families and anyone else who might be caught up in the violence he was attempting to trigger.

Sorry - he is a criminal - an absolute criminal. And Pravit has relieved himself of all credibility by willfully ignoring this.