Death of 'Uncle SMS' puts govt in focus
Ruling camp under pressure to change its hands-off stance over lese majeste law
Lese majeste detainee Amphon "Akong" Tangnoppakul, known as "Uncle SMS", succumbed to cancer at the Bangkok Remand Prison Hospital yesterday morning.
Amphon's wife, Rosmalin Tangnoppakul, was told that the prisoner - one of Thailand's most controversial lese majeste convicts - was still able to take his medication early yesterday but then he suddenly died around 9.10am.
His death will most likely rekindle controversy about the lese majete law, which led to his conviction and a staggering 20-year prison term.
While the death has politically embarrassed the Democrat Party, under whose reign the charges were brought against Amphon, Yingluck Shinawatra's government, which has vowed never to support any moves to amend the law, might face pressure from the red shirts.
However, with MPs in both government and opposition blocs not likely to support or sponsor any amendments to the lese majeste law, Amphon's death might not make any serious difference to the momentum of the campaign against it.
Grief-stricken Rosmalin broke down in tears as she told the press outside the prison hospital that she did not know what to say.
"I can't take in any information," she said.
Witnesses said Amphon's body appeared to be very bloated in the stomach area, suggesting a possible liver complication. The body was taken to the Forensic Institute, where it was to undergo an autopsy today with a red-shirt medical doctor and a relative in the room as witnesses.
Amphon was sentenced to 20 years in prison for sending four text messages deemed defamatory to Her Majesty the Queen to then-prime minister Abhisit Vejjajiva's personal secretary.
The sentence was handed down late last year and the case won much publicity both locally and overseas, especially since it was believed that the mobile-phone number could have been stolen and Amphon, 60 at the time, might not in fact have sent those messages.
About 30 supporters were present at the prison hospital yesterday, including Assistant Professor Puangthong Pawakapan of Chula-longkorn University's political science faculty.
The professor is a member of the Public Campaign Committee pushing for amendments to the lese majeste law.
"This is the biggest tragedy of the law. The more it is enforced, the less merciful it becomes. He wouldn't have died if he had been granted bail and given the opportunity to get proper medical care," Puangthong said.
Handing down harsh punishment to offenders would only create a climate of fear.
The maximum penalty for a single lese majeste offence is 15 years in prison.
Suda Rangkupan, a key member of the red-shirt movement and a linguistics lecturer at Chulalong-korn University, was also at the hospital. Tearfully crying out that the law is "unjust", Suda said Amphon was not provided adequate medical care.
"End the ordeals now," she said, referring to the 11 other people detained under the lese majeste law.
Suda also led a group of people opposed to the law to the Criminal Court yesterday evening to mourn Amphon's death and call on the government to take immediate action in amending the controversial law and free prisoners of conscience.
Poonsuk Poonsukcharoen, one of Amphon's three defence lawyers, confirmed that the late prisoner had recently decided not to take the case to the Appeals Court because senior officials from the Corrections Department had told them that it might just be better to seek a royal pardon.
"Those who think we have not done enough have the right to their belief. We regret [his death] but we insist that we did our best. Everyone in society is partly responsible for this, including the justice system," Poonsuk said.
Rosmalin lit one incense stick 2.20pm to urge Amphon's spirit to follow his body as it was carried out in a rescue truck to the Forensic Institute.
"Akong come, Akong come," she called out as the truck carrying her ex-husband's body passed by her.
The body of Amphon will be borne today from the Institute of Forensic Medicine Police General, then on to the Justice Ministry, Government House, and Parliament House. A group of red shirts opposed to the lese mejeste law announced the route yesterday. The body will undergo the bathing rite in front of the Criminal Court on Ratchada-phisek Road.



Comments
Will Puea Thai continue to
Will Puea Thai continue to betray those who put it in power? Or will they 'woman up' and take a stand for what's right and what their constituents have been calling for, what they elected this government to achieve :
The Nitirat has done the ground work. What's required is the commitment to their constituents and the follow through that those constituents counted on when they voted Puea Thai, which has since collapsed into Shinawatra II : the party of one.
Nitirat is a fraud - and so
Nitirat is a fraud - and so is the LM crusade Prachatai & their friends at the US State Dept. are on. Uncle SMS threatened the lives of Thailand's head of state and his family - which would land you 20 years in prison in any country, not just Thailand. It is a serious, intolerable crime to threaten ANYONE'S life.
Now that we know the contents of the SMS we can stop pretending he was a victim. But if you want to still pretend, at least be a little more realistic and stop blaming the army and start blaming Thaksin's paid-for rabble rousers who incited this emotional old man in the first place. All he was doing was repeating the garbage, threats, and treason coming from UDD's stage 24/7 and splashed across the pages of "political prisoner" Somyot Goebbels.
Tony 'would land you 20
Tony
'would land you 20 years in prison in any country'
In any other country he would have been found not guilty. The judge said in summing up ' The prosecution have not proved conclusively that the text messages were sent by Ah Kong' He was found guilty anyway.
If the judge had done the right thing and found him not guilty he too would have been accused of being an anti monarchist. paid by Thaksin red shirt. So he did what was expected of him and found Ah Kong guilty.
Betty is right and, as usual,
Betty is right and, as usual, Tony is wrong. He's wrong because he just concocts propaganda. Thanks for making sense Betty.
Betty is right and, as usual,
Betty is right and, as usual, Tony is wrong. He's wrong because he just concocts propaganda. Thanks for making sense Betty.
It was his phone - he was at
It was his phone - he was at the rally. He is liable.
This is not an issue of "free speech" it is an issue of a violent mob making death threats and someone paying the price either for his own crime, or the crime of a tremendous coward who let an aging, unhealthy old man die in prison in his stead.
Either way you cut it "Betty," it is just another facet of what absolute scum leads this movement and to what lengths they are willing to go to exploit ignorant people and leverage the tragedy of where their loyalty gets them to advance their own political agenda. I guess that includes you and US-funded Prachatai & Co. as well.
"Will Puea Thai continue to
"Will Puea Thai continue to betray those who put it in power? "
Yes they will, they have no reason not to and every reason to continue doing so. In Thailand, betrayal is the norm. It works.
"Or will they 'woman up' and take a stand for what's right and what their constituents have been calling for, what they elected this government to achieve :"
No they won't. The nee to do so is not on their moral radar.
"The end of the Royal Thai Army's status 'above the law', its 'right' to coup; to be enshrined in a new Constitution."
Not going to happen for as long as Yingluck (and by extension, Thaksin) are toadying up to the imagined 'royalty'. The 'royal' triumvirate of HMK, HMQ, Prem have made Yingluck and her government look like brown-noses of the first order. No wonder Prem smiles a lot, he cannot prevent the return of Thaksin so e will be delighted to have castrated him instead. Only fools and children need to identify with heroes to make them feel good about themselves. Check out the royalist sycophants in every monarchy, they're all the same, unimaginative and psychologically challenged.
The release of all political prisoners, especially victims of the Royal Thai Army's lese majeste inquisition.
Not going to happen. Those imprisoned in the body, those imprisoned in the spirit and those who died at the command of the 'hia' are merely bargaining chips to ensure Thaksin's continued privilege, and when his former cronies take government house again, the rape of Thailand will continue unabated. This much must now be plain to all.
"The Nitirat has done the ground work. What's required is the commitment to their constituents and the follow through that those constituents counted on when they voted Puea Thai, which has since collapsed into Shinawatra II : the party of one."
Naive. Why should Thaksin and his proxies worry? They have power now. Promises are only for when you want to get it, and one old man more or less is not going to trigger a revelation for them, nor any change in their reprehensible behaviour. Reprehensible behaviour is an integral part of the Thai culture that Jack built.
Postman I agree with a
Postman I agree with a surprisingly large number of the points you just made - only people like Akong and Somyot are NOT political prisoners. Both are guilty of threatening violence - a punishable crime in any country.
I disagree with the opaque nature of the Thai legal system, and a lot of how they do things - but these men are criminals, not political prisoners. Their crime isn't insulting people, their crime is promoting violence and making threats - intolerable crimes and intolerable for those that truly support progress and democracy. Likewise, PAD leaders who advocate violence must also go to jail.
It cannot be tolerated - it certainly cannot be defended as "free speech" lest we compromise and diminish REAL political prisoners.
Do you concede, that Akong was at the UDD rally as he said, that his phone was used, and that death threats were sent? Perhaps the court did not adequately prove they were sent by him particularly, but is he, a grown man, not responsible for how his phone is used? Under US law would he still not be found liable? Yes he would.
Please take this short
Please take this short survey. Thanks
http://www.surveymonkey.com/s/N97FXXS
Well - thanks to Andrew
Well - thanks to Andrew Marshall of ThaiStory - we know EXACTLY what "poor" Uncle SMS said - he threatened the lives of Thailand's head of state and his family - which would land you 20 years in prison (unless proven mentally ill) in even the most progressive democracies.
Why the US government which funds Prachatai - has on the books 18 USC § 876 - Mailing threatening communications - which would send someone like Amphon "Akong" Tangnoppakul to prison for up to 20 years just for sending such SMS's to an average American - saying nothing of what would happen to him for threatening the life of the President.
So, Pravit, you go on using this man's death as a political football - but the case is over - and you can thank clumsy Andrew Marshall. At least without knowing the contents of the SMS we could have had room to doubt - now we know for sure he didn't go to jail for "free speech," he committed an internationally recognized crime!
Tony, It is amazing how two
Tony,
It is amazing how two people can read the same text and draw such different conclusions. I read the texts of the SMS messages and concluded that an elderly retired man could not possibly have written them. The message writer kept talking about the group he was part of (the group that would take revenge), when we know for certain that Ah Kong never participated in any of the public events. The messages also used crude language that a grandfather would never use (that is, unless he were a "maeng da").
I thank AMM for making them public. It makes so clear that a totally innocent man died at the hands of a judicial mob. And I thank Tony for showing how preposterous it was to accuse Ah Kong.
Cliff - in court Akong
Cliff - in court Akong ADMITTED he was at the red shirt rally!!! He just claims he didn't send the SMS's. This comes from your own Thai Political Prisoners pro-Thaksin propaganda clearinghouse - not the government.
Someone threatened the safety and lives of others through those SMS's - and you have to ask yourself, if it was from his phone, but not from Akong himself - then who? What spineless coward in the red shirt movement would do something like that, and allow a sickly old man to take the fall for it?
No matter which way you cut it - the SMS's were criminal - you'd go to jail in ANY COUNTRY for threatening other people's lives - it is not free speech, and the red shirt movement, instead of defending him, exploited him UP TO AND AFTER HIS DEATH. Carrying his coffin around like a trophy.... shame on all of you.
Tony has made a huge
Tony has made a huge discovery: Amphon went to a red shirt rally. His source is PPT. At PPT is says: "At the time, Ampol was said to have been blacklisted as a hard-core member of the red shirts of Samut Prakan province by the Internal Security Operations Command." That means he was accused of this by ISOC. Amphon hmself denied this, and stated that he had attended both red shirt and yellow shirt rallies.
As we know, Tony doesn't give a fig for truth. He just wants to twist his concocted "facts" into a laughable "discovery" that is nothing of the sort.
But it is that "discovery" that is enough for Tony to decide Amphon was guilty and to engage in his usual slander. What a fascist dolt! Amphon was guilty of being a red shirt sympathizer!
A heartless, fascist propagandist of the first order.
From Thai Political Prisoner:
From Thai Political Prisoner: "Another Lese Majeste Case Sent to the UN:"
"Mr Ampon said that he had gone to the demonstration by the UDD when they were gathering near Rajadamnoen Avenue many times in the afternoon."
He was at the rally, it was his phone, the SMS's contained overt, specific death threats. If it wasn't Ampon, it was some spineless red shirt using his phone and then allowing an old man to be carted off to die in jail in his stead.
Either way you cut it, it is another brutal expose as to how depraved, illegitimate, and dangerous the UDD is. It was Ampon's phone - he is at least partly liable for how it is used unless he reported it stolen.
Now that we know the facts, and that Albert Park is an overt liar- simply picking a TPP story at random and putting words into my mouth, maybe we can start meeting in the middle on this issue. The Thai legal system is flawed and needs to be fixed. The LM laws however are being used against a violent seditious, foreign-funded movement against people promoting and threatening violence - not conducting "Free Speech."
Far from a random post from
Far from a random post from PPT, but from its page on Amphon and his case, listed under "Convictions".
As mentioned, Amphon also attended PAD rallies, so what's the point of your accusation. It seems to be nothing more than fascist nonsense and irrelevant for everyone but you and ISOC.
As for putting words in your mouth, I would never go anywhere so foul.
The spinelessness resides with those who can show no human feelings towards the weak and powerless while supporting horrid ruling class repression.
Ampon SAID he went to PAD
Ampon SAID he went to PAD rallies - but we have proof only that his phone sent the death threat SMS's from a UDD rally that he also admitted to attending.
That's what you're not getting. Whatever he said, or denied, all we can go off of is what we have proof of. We have proof his phone, at a rally he claimed himself he attended, sent death threats. That would land him in prison in ANY COUNTRY.
Feeling "sorry" for someone has nothing to do with dealing out impartial justice. Using emotional appeals is intellectually dishonest - Albert. If he committed a crime, he must pay for it. If he is sick - he must be taken care of but that doesn't exempt him from paying for his crimes.
Now Albert - please realize - you just denied he was at a UDD rally, now you admit he was but claim he was at PAD rallies too. You are bouncing around because you are a liar crafting a disingenuous narrative - and as I poke holes in it with facts from websites YOU YOURSELF recommend - you rewrite it, shamelessly contradicting what you said not 30 minutes ago!
Again, more fabrication. You
Again, more fabrication. You make claims that are unsupportable. You are the one who rewrites and your claim to use "facts" are themselves fabrications, as I show time and again.
You claim I said Amphon wasn't at a red shirt rally, which is a complete fabrication: Amphon denied he was a rabid red shirt as claimed by ISOC. I stated that he was at both red and yellow rallies. So what? Being at a rally PROVES nothing.
And, there is nothing I can see in the PPT post you refer to that says the offending messages were sent from the UDD rally site at Rachaprasong.
At the PPT post you mention, there is this: "Ampon said that he had gone to the demonstration by the UDD when they were gathering near Rajadamnoen Avenue many times in the afternoon. He said that he also went to the protest of the pro-royalist and nationalist People’s Alliance for Democracy (PAD) many times as well, but he is not ally to any political group."
Tony. How do you know the
Tony.
How do you know the messages came from Ah Kongs phone, or were sent from the red shirt rally.
The way I understand it, the phone ID number can be copied and used in any phone.
Yeah Betty - and Amphon could
Yeah Betty - and Amphon could have been cloned, his phone duplicated, and holographic projections used to frame him - but to what end? Why a sickly old man everyone would be sure to feel sorry for? Seems like, if anything, his own UDD buddies framed him for the exact purpose of riding his tragedy, then literally his corpse around to advance their and Thaksin's agenda.
It was his phone - at a rally he admitted he attended, where the UDD leaders on stage were making similar death threats on a daily basis. Face the facts - he was incited to make those comments, or someone used his phone and sent them on his behalf - by demagogic Thaksin lackeys knowing full well they made their comments with absolute impunity while anyone in the mob tempted to follow suit would be thrown under the bus - something they intentionally planned to exploit for political gain.
Since Amphon never reported his phone stolen, he'd have been at least partially responsible for sending a threatening communication even under most Western nations' laws. Of course - far fetched conspiracy theories like yours are not entirely impossible, just as clones & holograms are not entirely impossible, but improbable.
Amphon sent death threats via
Amphon sent death threats via SMS against Thailand's head of state. If he sent such death threats to even a regular citizen in any Western country, he would a similar penalty of up to 20 years in prison.
What I see here on Prachatai is a disgraceful, fact devoid appeal to authority based solely on his age and health, and now the spinning of wild conspiracy theories that simply don't add up.
The most bizarre is the suggestion that the "Democrats framed him," and in particular took his phone ID and copied it to make it appear Amphon, the most pitiful and sympathy invoking UDD dupe you will ever meet, sent vicious death threats so they could throw him in prison and surely incite the emotions of people around the world.
What utter absurdity - if anything, the UDD framed him - but most likely he was incited by the daily calls of violence made on the UDD stage, in the midst of a violent, armed uprising, in the heat of the moment to make his criminal threats.
When you attempt to frame this as "free speech," you endanger real freedom observed by responsible people, in favor of backing a criminal, treasonous, deceitful, exploitative Pro-Thaksin movement. Shame on you all.