American netizen jailed in latest abuse of Thai lèse-majesté laws
Reporters Without Borders is shocked by the two-and-a-half-year sentence imposed on American blogger Joe Gordon by a Bangkok court today for insulting the Thai royal family and deplores the increase in so-called lèse-majesté crimes in Thailand.
“Although it means a reduction in his original penalty, we are shocked by this sentence, the latest in a long series of lèse-majesté convictions,” the press freedom organization said.
“We are witnessing a game of one-upmanship in the penalties imposed on Thai netizens. Since it took office, the government of Prime Minister Yingluck Shinawatra has shown itself to be worse than its predecessor. In just four months, the number of allegations, prosecutions and convictions on lèse-majesté grounds is higher than for the whole of last year.
“The government must put an end to this repressive policy and repeal the lèse-majesté law and the Computer Act, two anti-freedom pieces of legislation.
“We call on the authorities to release Joe Gordon and the many other netizens and journalists imprisoned for lèse-majesté and to call a halt to the prosecution of the director of the online newspaperPrachatai, Chiranuch Premchaiporn, better known by the online name Jiew, whose trial is still in progress.”
Gordon, a Thai-born American, was arrested and remanded in custody in May this year while he was on holiday in Thailand. He was officially charged on 30 August with lèse-majesté for translating excerpts of the banned biography of King Bhumibol Adulyadej by Paul Handley, “The King Never Smiles”, on his blog.
At first he denied all the charges, but subsequently pleaded guilty on 10 October thereby avoiding a five-year prison term. His lawyer, Anon Nampha, said his client would not appeal but hoped for a royal pardon.
Thailand’s lèse-majesté law is among the most restrictive legislation in the world as far as freedom of express and freedom of information are concerned. However, Prime Minister Yingluck announced after her election victory on 3 July that it should not be used inappropriately.
In a contradictory statement on 26 August, Deputy Prime Minister Chalerm Yubamrung said he was making the crime of lèse-majesté a priority. At the same time, there has been an increase in arrests and convictions.
Ampon Tangnoppakul, known as “Uncle SMS”, received a 20-year prison sentence on 23 November for sending text messages deemed to have insulted the monarchy. His case has now attracted international attention. The United States among others has expressed concern, saying such prosecutions violate the fundamental right to free expression.
Chiranuch faces a possible sentence of 20 years in prison under the Computer Crime Act for for not removing quickly enough comments posted on her website last year that were “damaging to the monarchy” (read the press release).
Somyos Prueksakasemsuk, former editor of the magazine Voice of Thaksin which was closed last year, has been held on remand for seven months for insulting the monarchy (read the press release).
Several netizens are still in prison for lèse-majesté offences. Surapak Phuchaisaeng is still awaiting a verdict in his prosecution for messages he posted on Facebook. Thanthawut Thaweewarodomkulwas sentenced on 15 March to 13 years in prison for articles he published on a website linked to the “Red Shirts” anti-government protesters, NorporchorUSA. The student blogger Norawase Yotpiyasathien was arrested on 5 August.
Thailand is listed as a "country under surveillance" in the Reporters Without Borders report on “Enemies of the Internet” and is ranked 153rd out of 178 countries in the Reporters Without Borders press freedom index.
[corrected version]



Comments
Gordon, a Thai-born American,
Is that factually correct?
I think that is factually incorrect. I think Chiranuch faces decades in prison under the Computer Crimes Act for removing others' comments from the Prachatai webboard that were “damaging to the monarchy”... just not quickly enough.
This seems pretty sloppy for RSF. The 'R' is for 'Reporters', right? This could have been written at the Bangkok Post, where there are no reporters, just stenographers, and where facts are regarded as peripheral and not deemed worth checking.
Yingluck Shinawatra: 'I am capable enough to make my own decisions'
ดีแต่พูด
If I speak in the tongues of men and of angels, but have not love, I am only a resounding gong or a clanging cymbal. Signifying a secular nothing.
There's still time to sign the petition calling for the abrogation of Article 112 and the release of all Thai Political Prisoners. But no time to waste shilly-shallying around. It will be presented to the Royal Thai Government tomorrow.
You're correct, JFL. Very
You're correct, JFL. Very sorry about that. We will inform the RSF about the mistakes. Thank you very much.
No need to apologize at all,
No need to apologize at all, I knew it was RSF and not yourselves! You do a great job in two languages and we're all (save one) very glad that you do persevere! All of us owe you a lot for your tireless work on our behalf. Please keep it up.
The mistake on Chiranuch by RSF is potentially damaging. People who know nothing of the case will read that Chirancuch herself posted material deemed to have insulted HM the King "on her blog"!
There is no excuse for that. I'll put it down to a new intern at RSF... probably hired at the suggestion of one of their institutional contributors. Paid by them as well. Their 'helpful suggestions' are hard to turn down, I'm sure. Especially when they 'cost you nothing'. Right.
I realize that funding is a problem. If you didn't take institutional money yourselves... you wouldn't be here. I used to send you 1000 baht a month, but when I realized what a small sum that was in your scheme of things I reallocated it to where I felt it would do more good. Individual contributions, mine and everyone else's, made up less than 1% of your funding at that point. I haven't checked on RSF but I imagine it's a similar figure there as well.
I am sympathetic to everything you do. KrungThai Bank's dropped their ADM transaction fee to zero... I'll pick up again at 100 baht a month rather than 1000. That's what we need : a few thousand people sending you 100 baht a month. When will we the people figure that out?
Point zero one of one percent of all Thais so doing would net you ฿660,000 per month, about your present institutional funding. Maybe we need a slogan like, "Whip the plutocrats with pocket change!"
Ninety-nine % of anything dwarfs one % of the same. You are publishing on a shoestring, you all need raises, and we can afford it!
If one in ten thousand of us faithfully coughs up 100 baht a month... better yet if each one in a thousand of us faithfully coughs up 10 baht a month for ten different 'enterprises'... we can ensure the independent existence of media run by people with the same interests as ourselves. If not... then not.
I've convinced myself. I'm coming home at 100 baht a month. Maybe two. The key, as someone once said, is just to show up.
I am intrigued by the assertion of a 10 October sentencing for Joe Gordon. Slip of the tongue was it? That was the date that Joe pled 'guilty'. Smack of an explicit 'done deal' with the USA as 'facilitator', much?
Yes, maybe the next time RSF
Yes, maybe the next time RSF and Prachatai go with hands open begging for more cash from US State Department's National Endowment for Democracy, they will discuss this - maybe Prachatai will make a case for NED to pay them more and leave RSF out of the loop - though that would reduce the fake legitimacy having so many "different" organizations saying the same thing (dispute being funded by the same handful of people with the same agenda.)
RSF's NED Funding:
http://en.rsf.org/income-and-expenditure-07-09-2009,34401.html
Also notice on http://en.rsf.org/annual-accounts-2010-21-07-2011,37870.html they say corporations and foundations - but refuse to list them - but we can guess with accuracy...
Prachatai's NED Funding:
http://www.ned.org/where-we-work/asia/thailand
http://landdestroyer.blogspot.com/2011/08/exposed-indy-newspaper-funded-by-us.html
The king and royal family
The king and royal family gave openly speeches not to arrest anyone criticize him or his family fair or unfair. This government has never listened, continue processing just for their benefit in order to discredit our beloved king and Jakri dynasty. We Thai people don't care what others talked or criticized our royal. But these dirty politician animals take advantages of these situations!
Yes, THIS GOVERNMENT -
Yes, THIS GOVERNMENT - something all the hand wringers and 112 whiners never mention - THIS GOVERNMENT, Chalerm, Yingluck and Thaksin who are pursuing by far the harshest LM campaign ... and here's the reason why...
http://landdestroyer.blogspot.com/2011/12/us-feigns-concern-over-freedom-of.html
Please note that Prachatai IS funded by the US State Department via the National Endowment for Democracy....
listed under Foundation for Community Educational Media...
http://www.ned.org/where-we-work/asia/thailand