It may be time to take off the blindfold

In Thailand, reality and its acknowledgement have a way of being supplanted by fiction and denial.

Take for instance the gathering of some 10,000 red shirts last Sunday at Rajprasong intersection to mark the fourth anniversary of the 2006 coup and the fourth month since the military cracked down on the movement.

The one thing conspicuously missing from media coverage was the angry messages emblazoned on the corrugated iron wall outside CentralWorld, which is being rebuilt after the red shirts allegedly burned it down in the aftermath of the crackdown.

Until late Sunday afternoon, the walls were plastered with colourful feel-good propaganda calling for national unity, which were later replaced by angry messages aimed squarely at the established old elite saying things that cannot be reproduced here or anywhere else without the risk of violating the lese majeste law.

At about 7pm that Sunday evening, a number of red shirts stood in front of the wall airing their anger and political grievances. The very next day, these messages were removed and life went on as if they were never there to begin with.

The 25-metre long wall of corrugated iron is still there, with absolutely no sign of there being any colourful messages written on it - it's just bare and grey.

But on Sunday night, the wall carried heartfelt messages from a substantial number of red shirts before someone decided to sanitise the wall and remove it from the history of Thai politics, circa 2010.

A Western photojournalist, who understood the meaning of some of those messages, told this writer about how uneasy they made him feel and was wondering what he should do with the photographs.

The gap between what many Thai people want to believe about certain issues and the reality of the beliefs held by some red-shirt Thais has never become wider. The April-May protests and the subsequent crackdown, which led to a combined total of 91 deaths, only served to widen the gap and instil more anger and paranoia. The gap between what is spoken and admitted privately, and what is recited and dismissed publicly is widening and exacting an increasing cost on Thai society.

On Tuesday, Surakiart Sathirathai, who was foreign minister under Thaksin Shinawatra and distanced himself from the premier before the September 2006 coup, said in a speech at Siam University that "people who defame and attack the [royal] institution" are "becoming more visible". He acknowledged this to be one of the two root causes for the current political divide, though he failed to explain why he thinks that might be the case.

The messages on the wall were unprecedented and their almost-immediate removal is symptomatic of a censored society, while those who disagree with the red shirts are too afraid to ask why so many red shirts think and believe in the things they do.

Denying what a substantial number of the population thinks and believes will not pull the country out of the current political impasse.

A Pandora's box was opened when the coup ousted Thaksin four years ago. The least we can do now, after 91 people have died, is to start acknowledging what others feel and ask ourselves why.

Comments

Denying what a substantial

Denying what a substantial number of the population thinks and believes will not pull the country out of the current political impasse.

What a substantial number of the population believes is unimportant if it is not congruent with the "elite" line.

It is up to the population of Thailand to reconcile themselves to the "elite" line. To reconcile themselves to the current political impasse. To become impassive.

The "elite" awaits that collapse, that reconciliation.

Belief through

Belief through indoctrination. Forced, coerced - and perverse.

Lets look at this credibly:

Lets look at this credibly: The image often repeated in the media was of the burned down luxury New World centre which now has a “memory wall” next to the complex supported by the metropolitan administration and local anti-democracy bourgeois elements. There was nothing "feelgood" about this. It was revolting. This site consists of connected placards where passersby can write commemorative comments on the boards (in Thai and English) such as “We miss you Central World”; or “We love you Central world”, and so on. But this selective process of remembrance has the political purpose of marking as completely insignificant or erasing from the memory-nation the 89/91 mostly subaltern killed and nearly 1,900+ injured, most in this precinct. This counter-work by Sombat for instance is against the oppressive and dominant discourse of the state embodied in the dehumanizing statements erected at the New World centre. But there is something unreal and fabricated about these statements such that they would enable individuals to recall a past in order to inscribe a new sense of directed meaning to the present. It is state cunning and symptomatic of an overall attempt by the fascist regime to construct a new order meaning to the present that annihilates all “other” counter-hegemonic voices, and for that matter even the process of grassroots democracy established under ex-PM Thaksin Shinawatra...

Certainly what you say about

Certainly what you say about the reaction in the aftermath of the inferno is right on.

I'm still stuck on who burned the place down. Was this just "urban renewal" without a permit? It was certainly well organized and efficiently carried out... in an area under total lock down by The Regime in the direct aftermath of their May Massacre. I wouldn't be surprised to learn that the major retailers have come out ahead financially after collecting insurance on their losses.

Who burned the retail center of Bangkok? Same ones who killed all the people there?
Will we ever know? Will they ever be brought to justice?

Who killed Somchai Neelaphijit?
Will we ever know? Will they ever be brought to justice?

Who killed Phra Supoj Suvacano?
Will we ever know? Will they ever be brought to justice?

Who is killing the Red shirts even now?
Will we ever know? Will they ever be brought to justice?