Sunday, 21 March 2010

A rose by any other name would smell as much

It’s been a bad week for the scam artists.

Sorawan Sirisuntarin, who markets under the name ‘Pa Cheng’, has been charged with violating the Pharmaceuticals Act. She had been peddling a panacea called Maha Bambad at 1000 baht a wee bottle and an eye lotion called Jiaranai Petch.

Supposedly the result of an 18-year fermentation process (so we assume she now has 17 years worth of unusable stock), her cure-all was found by lab tests to contain bacteria that can cause nausea, vomiting, diarrhoea and gangrene. Her eye-drops were highly acidic and could cause irritation and blindness.

Although she insists that her products work (and help counter global warming in some unexplained way) and she has a number of convinced devotees, she has agreed to stop production.

Meanwhile a BBC Newsnight investigation into the ADE651 bomb detector and other similar ‘electro-statically powered’ devices has shown that the wand-wielding hand-set was nothing more than an empty plastic box and that their pre-programmed cards were unprogrammable retailers’ tags costing pennies.

Over 500 of these contraptions are currently being used by the army at close to a million baht a pop, and other government agencies have ordered more.

They have apparently given false negative readings in incidents that cost lives. They also give false positives, according to dozens of detainees in the south who have been locked up because a soldier’s rod waggled in their direction..

The reaction of the authorities responsible for their procurement and continued use has not quite been on the lines of Pa Cheng. Among the blanket denials, Thep Thaug and Khunying Pornthip have either been sadly misinformed or are telling whopping porkies, and Gen Anupong got himself into a very nasty snit that makes one wonder if a man of his temper should have his finger on the coup button.

But all good scam artists firmly, sincerely and ardently believe their own scams. Neither Pa Cheng nor the gimcrack gizmo makers are giving up.

Since she can’t sell her stuff as medicine and she does have a fair few tanks of stuff in various stages of decomposition, Pa Cheng has developed another bomb detector.

This consists of her magic fluid in what looks suspiciously like an old Yakult bottle with the labelling scraped off. The specially trained operator holds the bottle in his fist and slowly walks round the area to be checked. If the bottle starts to feel warm, then this is a sign that there are explosives nearby.

The heat is allegedly caused by malolactic maceration triggered by the micro-cloacaferic radiation emitted by all materials, though for ease of explanation, Pa Cheng just refers to the ‘fluence’. Pa Cheng’s liquid is ‘tuned’ to the frequency of explosives.

It is important that the operator not be tired, have a temperature, feel grumpy, have used a mobile phone in the previous 24 hours, suffer from constipation or have a name containing the letter ‘no nu’, since any of these conditions will disturb the effect.

Army tests succeeded in finding one of five hidden hand grenades a third of the time. This was calculated as a success rate of 20% times 33%, or an amazing 660%. Army specialists, however, were reluctant to go ahead with procurement.

‘It’s rather suspicious that she’s only asking a couple of thousand baht per bottle,’ said one officer who refused to be named. ‘If this was a genuine article, we’d expect to pay hundreds of thousands of dollars. It would also look a bit more scientific if it had some flashing lights,’ he added.

The manufacturers of the GT200 have also come up with a new use for their product. New programmed cards have been developed which enable the detector to diagnose illnesses. So if a ‘malaria’ card is inserted into the black-box reader, and the device is held next to a patient, then the rod will twitch if the patient has malaria.

Cards have been developed for all major illnesses such as cancer, diabetes, erectile dysfunction, etc. Although the new cards are expensive at around $5000 each, major savings can be made by avoiding expensive and time-consuming lab tests, according to the manufacturers.

A demonstration at Government House revealed that the Prime Minister was suffering from fatigue, in-growing toe-nails and a condition described as ‘coalitionitis’, or an adverse reaction to political alliances. The PM remarked that ‘two out of three isn’t bad’, but did not identify which conditions he is actually suffering from.

Medical experts fell about laughing when shown the device, a reaction the manufacturers attribute to their vested interest in old-fashioned diagnostic techniques. Only the Army Medical Corps seemed to show a genuine interest in the device.

‘We’re hopeful that it will help us to detect malingerers,’ said a doctor from Bhumibol Hospital. ‘You’d be surprised how many soldiers think they can fool us into giving them a medical discharge when there’s really nothing wrong with them. But it’s not that easy to fool the Thai military.’


About author: Bangkokians with long memories may remember his irreverent column in The Nation in the 1980's. During his period of enforced silence since then, he was variously reported as participating in a 999-day meditation retreat in a hill-top monastery in Mae Hong Son (he gave up after 998 days), as the Special Rapporteur for Satire of the UN High Commission for Human Rights, and as understudy for the male lead in the long-running ‘Pussies -not the Musical' at the Neasden International Palladium (formerly Park Lane Empire).

Comments

I have a proposal for the

I have a proposal for the sale of very effective military uniform, extremely lightweight, perfectly camouflaged (especially in mottled brown environments), guaranteed to distract the enemy and possibly send them into uncontrollable fits of laughter. A bargain at only 1,500,000 Baht per clear plastic package.

George, could you please pass on this once in a career offer to the relevant military stockists?

And the estimable Suthep now

And the estimable Suthep now has his personal imprimatur on the thing. Like he really needed any more excuses to look like a complete maroon - right?

You really couldn't make this stuff up...

I once had a "Secret Sam"

I once had a "Secret Sam" kit.

Thailand crisis quotes The

Thailand crisis quotes The Nation :

Further doubt was cast on the efficacy of the controversial GT200 explosive detector yesterday when panelists at a symposium at Chulongkorn University’s Faculty of Science concluded it was almost certainly a “hoax” and urged people in society to be more scientifically minded.

“I think [it's not intentional corruption] but ignorance. It’s a great hoax. Our society doesn’t question it as long as the users appear. Our society relies on superstition,” Jessada told The Nation.

Not me... I think it's intentional corruption... covered in a thin veneer of superstition perhaps, to make it "respectable".

But perhaps it is a difficulty with "book learning" among the Bangkok "elite". Apparently the progeny of the "elite" are having trouble getting into college. The answer is a different criteria for admission : morality! An even more alarming exercise of willful irrationality from the same blog :

Utumporn Jamornmann, director of the National Institute of Education Testing Service (NIETS), who is an expert in creating several national academic and aptitude tests to screen students for universities, said the project was a good start.

The country now does not have national morality tests due to the time limit for announcing national test results for hundreds of thousands of students.

“NIETS also wants to create national morality tests and already has forms for such tests. Academic tests are not enough. However, to test what is in people’s minds is very hard. We need to do research to guarantee the accuracy of the tests,” he said.

But to test what is in people’s minds is not very hard... read the description of how the judge in the secret "trial" of Darunee Charnchoengsilpakul did exactly that. It's well-known that the Dominicans were equally adept at rooting out heresy just a few hundred years ago in Spain as well.

Since the "elite" are by definition on a higher plane than all others in Thailand they are the natural candidates for "morality scholarships". Especially the sons and daughters of politicians.

Of course the truly alarming

Of course the truly alarming point is that everyone knows all that of this is fraud... yet accepts that... what... life is a fraud? Apparently.

Just gotta be the "defrauder" and not the "defraudee", then everything is Mercedes Benz and peace and light.

And of course the state religion is Buddhism. Just to make sure that nothing genuine is left "un-defrauded".

Post new comment

The content of this field is kept private and will not be shown publicly.
Comments are limited to a maximum of 2500 characters.
  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.
Image CAPTCHA
Enter the characters shown in the image.