Saturday, 20 March 2010

Da Torpedo’s molar abscess needs medical treatment outside prison

Daranee Charnchoengsilpakul was visited by her brother and a group of activists on the last day of the year allowed by the prison for visiting inmates.

On 30 Dec, Kittichai and the Palang Ruam Jai group went to visit Daranee at Khlong Prem Prison.  According to a member of the group, Kittichai travels every week from his home in Phuket to visit his youngest sister.  Kittichai told the activist that in the morning he had had to wait in a very long queue at the prison’s shop to buy groceries for his sister, as many people had come to visit convicted relatives before the New Year.

They met Daranee who put on a smiling face to greet them.  She extended her New Year blessings to democracy supporters, the UDD or red-shirt leaders, and the media, and her thanks to those who had sent her nearly 1,000 letters and postcards. 

She said the letters and postcards were very valuable to her, and she would try to communicate to the senders through the Palang Ruam Jai group.

Kittichai made a request for Daranee’s medical records from the prison’s hospital to be forwarded to a doctor who will take care of her treatment.  He was told by the prison’s Administrative Director that Daranee had been able to drink only milk, because she could not open her mouth wide or chew food normally. 

According to the group, those who wish to help Daranee can donate to her brother’s account:

Kittichai Charnchoengsilpakul
Savings account No: 297-1-25805-5
Bank of Ayudhya
Phunphol Road branch, Phuket

And letters and postcards can be sent to Daranee via the group to:

Daranee Charnchoengsilpakul
PO Box 58 Por Nor Sor (Phor)
Phrakhanong 
Bangkok 10110

Or e-cards to wemissyouda@gmail.com.

Comments

Good to hear that Daranee can

Good to hear that Daranee can still smile :) I hope that the "authorities" allow her to get the treatment she needs. I'm happy that her brother is such a good man. I am inspired by her quiet strength and acceptance.

There are so few people to admire in politics that we need to treasure those who do set a positive example that we can all profitably follow, and certainly let them know that they are not forgotten.

When asked what he was doing in jail Henry David Thoreau asked what Emerson was doing outside! Thoreau was playing at politics. Daranee is all in.

I'll send her another card this month and every month until she's free. I cannot imagine that she will serve 18 years in jail. We'll all be in jail with her if another, real government does not come into power and see to it that she's released before then.

In the mean time I will try to cheer her up, and on. And to keep the enormity of this government's crimes in persecuting her and the others, Boonyuen Prasertying and Suwicha Thakor, in mind at all times.

I suppose there are a

I suppose there are a number of people who have beliefs, stick to them and have sustained passion for them. for some commitment to their beliefs (and acting true to them)give meaning to their life.
Bloggers here must have found that politics gives meaning to their life somehow.
..(i'm not being sarcastic or anything here, just in case)..
just wonder how can people sustain their enthusiasm for something (politics, work, ..in fact for life in general.

off=topic comment, sorry.

off=topic comment, sorry.

Not so much off-topic as

Not so much off-topic as open-ended... I don't know how address the question of how to "sustain... enthusiasm for.. life in general".

Somedays it's easier than others, right ? :)

Any major dude will tell you... when the demon is at your door, in the morning it won't be there no more.

JFL is right: Life wasn't

JFL is right: Life wasn't meant to be easy! One step at a time is my guiding principle. (Happy NY, anyway...Keep the 'off-topics' rolling, Joy; They're interesting.)

Which reminds me - I recently introduced my students to the writing of Isabel Allende. They love it!

thanks JFL, thanks michael. I

thanks JFL, thanks michael. I suppose my problem is i want life to be ' happy" and that;s a selfish approach to everything. Guess i need to change the outlook.

Well, no it's not selfish to

Well, no it's not selfish to want to be happy.

There's happy and then there's happy... DTAC sells happy, but that's probably not what we have in mind.

Da is always reported to be smiling, but she's not DTAC happy. I'm sure her jailers don't allow her a phone. And her tooth hurts. Infection and pain aren't DTAC happy either.

But Da has done what was called for according to her point of view and given up on DTAC and accepted the consequences of her acts... and their fruits as well. For her acts are fruitful, they do have positive results.

It's easy to imagine that "resistance is futile"... but then there's Da. Who has resisted and continues to resist in the very belly of the beast. They've done their worst, or nearly, and Da has survived and continues to do what she can... plans to grow fruits and vegetables in prison when the opportunity presents itself.

So happy can be found in integrity, and Da has shown... me anyway... the way. An ordinary person doing extraordinary things. Brings a small smile to my face just to contemplate it.

I'm just a minor dude, but we can check with the major dudes and any one of them with half a heart will tell us... all he knows, the where to go, the what to do.. we can try to run but we can't hide from what's inside of us. We can run down the wrong road, running from the demon or chasing the will'o'the wisp, or we can slow down, get our bearings, and strike off in the real, right direction.

Da turned around and faced the demon that was scorching her back, bathing her with his fiery breath... and he shrunk, and faded, and what is left behind is the warmth emanating from her own warm heart happily beating in her breast, free and clear in prison, and she seemingly enjoys a happiness as large or as small as her own real concerns, and is unconcerned with what is beyond her control.

Thanks for yr post JFL. i

Thanks for yr post JFL. i will reread and think abt it more.

michael- I like Allende.

michael- I like Allende. Which one did you introduce to your students? La casa de los espíritus (The House of Spirits)?

Joy- The pursuit of happiness is one of the fundamental human needs. Don't feel bad about wanting happiness.

Happy 2010 to both!

G'day, Sub. It's 'City of the

G'day, Sub. It's 'City of the Beasts,' one of 2 she wrote for teenagers. She's one of my favorite writers. I wish she'd write more. I'm reading 'Eva Luna' at the moment, & dreading coming to the end. It's brilliant, full of luscious language (top marks to the translator for her part in the collaboration!), wonderful images & really superb subversive thought, plus the usual bizarre, rambling story, chock a-block with fascinating twists & turns. My idea of literary heaven!

I've always wondered why Thai writers haven't got into Magic Realism; the socio-political situation seems right for it - repressive, corrupt administrations, bizarre magico-religious beliefs, extremes of poverty & greed, hideous HR abuses, etc. I suppose it's like Joy said once - Thais don't read.

Looks forward to more

Looks forward to more discussion abt literary works (in relation to politics) from u guys and everyone else. I wish i could afford the luxuries of reading like michael. I have a task hanging over and tormenting me but hope that it will be done soon. i have just resolved to lead the big part of my life life like an efficient machine until that task is finished.

Thais don't read? Really?

Thais don't read? Really? Many Thais I met are avid readers even they majored in science at college. I don't know 'City of the Beasts'- in fact I don't even know Isobel Allende wrote for teenagers. Allende for teens, err.. aren't her books a bit too sensual for kids?.. Well, I suppose it's all different now, during my time it was stuff like Golding's 'Lord of the Flies', Orwell's 'Animal Farm' or Bronte's 'Wuthering Heights' (do they still teach these?). Allende isn't so well received in where I live; sensuality is a bit too much for the empiricist minds (hahaha). I like her anyway. 'The House of Spirits' introduced me to Pablo Neruda- a great Poet.

Agreed that Thai writers don't generally write in a genre of magic realism. The last master of Thai magic realism is probably Sunthorn Pu who passed away in mid 19th century. There's a contemporary writer, S. P. Somtow, whose line of work comes close to magic realism. His sci-fi thriller novels are said to be interwoven with Thai ghost stories. I've never read him so don't know whether he's any good.

I think SP somtow's "Jasmine

I think SP somtow's "Jasmine Night(s?)' is quite good. One of my ex-teachers told me she loves Wuthering Heights. She loves literature, very passionate abt it. It makes people like me feel guilty when talking to her bec right now i can;t devote my time to literature that much.

"One of my ex-teachers told

"One of my ex-teachers told me she loves Wuthering Heights. She loves literature, very passionate abt it."

You had a good teacher Joy. "Wuthering Heights" is a book I wish I had written. Passion, place, possession, ghost, rage, revenge, the love so intense that distorted a sense of dimension, and much of anything else came after this book. Kate Bush, a pop musician, wrote her hit to pay homage to this novel in the 1980s. Bush's song referenced many lines from the novel, eg. the catchy tune- 'Heathcliff, it's me Cathy, I come home...'.

A book that inspired music is truly special.

S.P. Somtow (in Thailand:

S.P. Somtow (in Thailand: Somtow Sucharitkul) is a very good writer indeed. "Jasmine Nights" is one of his most appreciated and accessible books, but I'd suggest to read "Vampire Junction", "Darker Angels", "Moon Dance" and "Starship and Haiku", in order to understand his literary production is a more comprehensive way. Also, a very good read (especially if associated with "Jasmine Nights") is Pira Sudham's "Monsoon Country" and "The Force of Karma".

I like "Monsoon Country' but

I like "Monsoon Country' but find the Force of Karma ...hmmm...
once i have time, i will certainly look up somtow's other works

If you are so pressed for

If you are so pressed for time you might try a short story. Take you less time to read The Handsomest Drowned Man in the World than you spend reading and writing here.

There are many wonderful shorter works in the world waiting to be read. Jorge Luis Borges wrote lots. Chekov did too. Italo Calvino wrote some wonderful short pieces. The Baron in the Trees is longer... but it's so good I always hate to come to the end.

None of these were written in English but all have been translated into English. Some people claim that the translations of Allende's works, for instance, are better than the original. Guy Davenport wrote lots of great short works in English, one of my favorites is C. Musonius Rufus.

If a picture is worth a thousand words there is a picture of your Cheshire cat as well as one of nought but his smile available online as well. And reading Alice at full length is a refreshing commentary on absurd and arbitrary politics.

I like Jorge Luis Borges.

I like Jorge Luis Borges. Calivo- so-so. Davenport-not bad. Chekhov- divine.

Now I remember I read "Jasmine Nights" many years back- fell to sleep in chapter 2. Don't think I'll read Somtow's 'vampire' collection; others might find his fictions interesting but they're just not my cup of tea. I like his Thai ghost "Mae Nak" opera, which I watched in BKK some time ago, nonetheless.

Mae Nak, a haunting female spirit, is someone who loves too much and doesn't know how to let go.

Where is this Ghost Nation of hers?

JFL: thanks for the short

JFL: thanks for the short stories. It's very kind of u to post link to the C cat. will look it up soon.
I tend to only pick and respond to things that catch my attention, sorry if my post appears irrelevant to the main thread (politics in this case).
Been thinking abt the MaeNark movie. I bet every Thai knows Mae Nark and i used to treat it as a ghost story (and also interesting depiction of Thailand in those days).
But the thing abt someone who can't let go sort of interests me more now. Been discussing this with close friend who told me maybe the thing u believe u can hold on to probably means nothing (Buddhist nothingness?) and i feel the permanent way to peace is to realize the fact that there's nothing that u can hold on to..or to be more correct..to get rid of the you..maybe that's what Meanark did when in the end she eventually let go of her husband.
That friend of mine said something along the same line, and now the thing that he feels can keep him going/sustain the belief in life is to live and work in order to make people he loves happy. Remind me of JFL's post abt Da a bit although there's definitely difference as well.

Now you're talkin'! I'm

Now you're talkin'! I'm interested in the Maha Chat, the story of Phra Wetsandorn. I cherish and stand in awe of the cultural setting which has grown up around it. I was fortunate enough to meet a few monks in Nan who have re-instituted the reading of the Maha Chat in their respective wats on a revolving basis, and I sat and listened to Matsii there myself a few years ago.

As with the story of the Buddha himself the renunciation of family responsibilities is discounted completely. Here's another take, in a short story by Sri Daruang.

I always try to make "sense", in my own dim light, of stories of such awesome power. I tell myself that Phra Wetsandorn exhibited wisdom in "giving away" what he never possessed to begin with; for who can claim other people as their own property, not least their mates and offspring?

Da's story is of the renunciation of the "respect" of her society for silence in the face of what she regarded as its duplicity. I still have no real idea of what she actually said. Her words are accorded the power of the Gorgon's mask... they will turn us all to stone if we actually hear them.

Trying to make "sense" of the story of the terrible power of the Gorgon's mask, again by my own dim lights, I imagine that it was integral to the transition from the feminine gods of matriarchal neolithic culture to the masculine, "modern" Apollonian gods of today.

Still so obviously holding sway.

JFL, I have read the short

JFL, I have read the short story, "Matsii"(was it written by someone called ..what's the pen-name...mmm "An-chan" ? )
Seems to be a feminist type of story and once i had a chance to discuss with a grp of Thai postgrads..one guy got a bit upset by the story(he is a nice student but he dislikes feminism). I'm now half way through yr recommended short story (finally, more time to read now)

sorry i got it wrong, the

sorry i got it wrong, the author seems to be Sri Dao Ruang.

MaeNark movie? What? Where?

MaeNark movie? What? Where? Is it on DVD? Subtitles?

IMDB.com says the 2005 movie

IMDB.com says the 2005 movie was the 20th film viersion.

But u are not interested in

But u are not interested in Mae-nark, I think. sort of boring for you.

I'm not going to fall into

I'm not going to fall into your trap, Joy - been there done that when discussing W B Yeats etc.

Lets just leave it at: We are each entitled to like what we like, and be bored by what we are bored by:)

I'm not setting any trap for

I'm not setting any trap for you!!!!!!!!
anyway , sorry, I know i made personal attack on you intentionally@!:-P ( to satify my own maliciousness haha)

It seems to me (as far as I

It seems to me (as far as I can remember) that once u pass through earlier chapters of Jasmine Nights, the book becomes more interesting.

Wonder where is Plaadip?

Sorry I haven't had time to

Sorry I haven't had time to respond. I've been following this great "off-topic" (not really!) thread, but too busy to contribute. Frustrating, because the discussion's great, & people are coming out of the woodwork to contribute.

I agree that Somtow's 'Jasmine Nights' is a good read (although a bit 'forced' with all its allusions to the classics, etc., which verge on pretentiousness.), but I'm not such a fan of his later stuff. His genre is fantasy & horror now. I wish he had kept exploring the same path as J Nights. He seems to be devoting himself to opera these days - I saw his 'Thaiis' last year (hideously bad!), and 'Boheme' more recently (much better). I've got a few of Pira Sudham's, which are interesting, although not very high quality writing.

For me, Sunthorn's stuff can't be described as 'magic realism' (MR). It's entirely of the wrong period. The 'realism' in MR seems to me to always be a very harsh & brutal reality, informed by the authors' understanding of society from modern social theory, including Marxism & the feminisms, and the growing Human Rights movement. (That's why I don't think this discussion is really "off-topic".)

I was doing Google searches on MR, and MR vs fantasy, and came up with a site full of MR short stories : http://www.magicalrealism.co.uk It's an online magazine, "Serendipity". I got to it from a link on the Man Booker site. Posters on this thread may find it interesting - Joy especially, because of her limited time. I've read 2 short pieces already, both rather innocent & child-like, but quite fun. One is a Brothers Grimm piece, so I assume the editors wouldn't agree with my comments re Sunthorn.

I wonder how we could get Prachatai to open a page for discussion of this kind?

michael, thanks a lot for the

michael, thanks a lot for the link and yr very informative post. BTW, maybe submarine's version of Maenark is more interesting (opera?). I watched Maenark when i was a kid ..long time ago. Not sure if there are new versions with Eng subtitles. But u might not like it. a foreign friend of mine commented that this sort of theme bores him.Depends on individual taste i think. Most stuff i like appear boring to the majority of people.

I studied Sunthorn Pu in

I studied Sunthorn Pu in primary school (like most Thais I think).Maybe some other Thais can comment abt him? I only remember 'Pra apai manee"..

michael- Sunthorn Phu's

michael- Sunthorn Phu's fiction like Pra Apai Manee was 'magical' before a Koncept of magic realism came into being. The story of Pra Apai Manee is anti-imperialism-- (an Ism for modern explanation, that is). On Somtow, I agree that most of his operas, including Mae Nak, the one I saw many years back, weren't so impressive. But I think people like Khun Somtow needs support, rather than criticism. For years the man has been working hard to make Thais appreciate opera, and what he's been saying - that opera isn't solely a product of Western culture- doesn't put him in a comfort zone of mainstream opera. I doubt also that he receives financial support/subsidies from the State (this makes opera or other forms of Art inaccessible for the masses- the elitism of art has little to do with art itself. There's no such thing as 'high art' or 'high poetry'; only Art and the other kind-- I should have said this when we last discussed Yeats).

Joy- you have a good Friend there. Stick with him, be with him, if you want your life to be happy. Most cannot "think" beyond the 'me, myself, and I'-- My land; My place; My possession; My work; My book; My idea; My courage; My Principle (big P); My practice (small p); My time; My history; My humanity--- My, Mine, Mine. If the me, myself, and I are removed, we might begin to give Humanity a chance-- Love (in a widest sense), even.

Hobby- Poetry is honesty, not snobbery. Here's a pint of Draught Poetry, serving extra cold with no Pride or Pretence.

"And it was at that age... Poetry arrived
in search of me. I don't know, I don't know where
it came from, from winter or a river.
I don't know how or when,
no, they were not voices, they were not
words, nor silence,
but from a street I was summoned,
from the branches of night,
abruptly from the others,
among violent fires
or returning alone,
there I was without a face
and it touched me."

Opening stanza of "Poetry" by Pablo Neruda.

Have a good week everyone.

submarine, Thanks for the

submarine, Thanks for the great post.
I'm still struggling to go beyond the 'I" , 'my', but i think this is the only way to live so i have to keep on trying.

I did not mean to imply it

I did not mean to imply it was 'snobbery', just that most of it doesn't 'touch me'.

Although I do seem to recall liking a few limericks in my younger days - now that's poetry to philistines like me:)

I Poetry Crapped and

I Poetry

Crapped
and UNTOUCHED
but
no snobbery
Is
Poetry
According to Whom

II Limerick

Limerick
Sweet lime
to
lick
Pick a rhyme
and
kick
...

Joy- Thanks for your compliment; but I don't know Much about Thailand. I wish I know more.
Pladip - 何 日 君 再 来?

Sub, you seem to know so much

Sub, you seem to know so much about Thailand/Thai literature . Wish Plaadip joined the discussion again. He might add the Japanese side of things.

"michael- Sunthorn Phu's

"michael- Sunthorn Phu's fiction like Pra Apai Manee was 'magical' before a Koncept of magic realism came into being." Yes, I agree, and so was a great deal of literature from many cultures "magical before..etc.". Which is why they can't be labelled 'Magic Realism'. It's important to realise that such 'labels' are generally created for convenience by literary critics to identify 'movements', which spring up as the result of the state of thought in particular periods and, sometimes, geographical locations. The authors usually don't invent these labels (the exception being movements which are consciously created, such as 'dada', sometimes with a manifesto.), & indeed they often resist them. Scholars find the labels useful, because they enable particular kinds of analysis, linking contemporary social, political & aesthetic influences, for example. However, to say that Swift (18thC), e.g., is a Magic Realist, simply because Gulliver's Travels had elements of magic and elements of the 'real' or 'natural', would be fairly pointless and glaringly anachronistic because, for example, literary Realism & all of its influences had not occurred. Swift was a very skillful social critic, BTW.

Bangkok Opera does receive public funding. There's a string of logos on their site. I'm an opera lover, but I have difficulty accepting the funding of such an expensive & largely irrelevant artform in a culture where there is a great need for real cultural expression, & very little encouragement for it. The Misery of Culture does virtually nothing to foster emerging creativity. It seems more dedicated to stamping it out. Somtow identified himself strongly as a conservative in a speech published in his 50th birthday compilation, in which he condemned and tastelessly ridiculed Nobel Laureate Wole Soyinka for rejecting, for political reasons, an invitation to present literary awards in Bangkok after the most recent military coup. In his foreword, he called Wole's reaction "...a typically non-Thai misreading of the entire situation."

Let me elaborate why I wrote

Let me elaborate why I wrote "K"oncept, in stead of concept. In a language of human-being walking on earth, concept, as being used in soft sciences (social & political sciences, and disciplines in Arts/Humanities that resort to the use of concept) stand on the foundation of philosophy. Immanuel Kant gave birth to it when he came up with a split between 'material phenomena' (things as they appear) and 'ideal phenomena' (things as they are). IOW, Kant distinguished 'mind' from 'matter'. It might sound simple now but what Kant discovered at the time was a major breakthrough; no other thinkers since ancient Greece ever accomplished this. He argued that if a terrain between these two phenomena can be mapped, Mankind might be able to move closer to the understanding of knowledge. This space, gap, or call it any name is of course the working of concept. Hence the German K. This is how concept came into being in Western philosophy; other cultures have their own conceptualisation of thought too, but it is the Western one that we use mostly in modern (secular) thinking. German thoughts were intertwined with nation-building. German Enlightenment thinkers as well as the Romantics poured their intellectual/artistic energy into a (re) unification of their Nation in 19th C. Via volktales which emphasize local dialect, myth, and magic such as those of the Grimm Bros, Germany led the way in creating a concept of magical realism. The Germans in fact drew their sources from other cultures and languages, Sanskrit, particularly. So some have argued that this magic realism should be understood as a universal concept as when Germans were busy building it, other parts of the world were also doing it (or even before; but genealogy isn't really an issue). Sunthorn Phu's tale fits in this concept of magical realism. You should ask any Thai kid of how they felt when they first came across characters such as Sinsamut or Sudsakorn (with his magic/flying horse). You must be able to read Thai to appreciate it.
(tbc.)

I won't comment on other

I won't comment on other people's politics. We all had to do what we had to do and be true to our values. I'm glad that even you disagree with Somtow's politics, you haven't boycott his art. Artists (Somtow included) are severely underfunded in Thailand. It's really frustrating as the foundation of our children's Education depends on the arts. We need more teachers who appreciate arts like you, and we need Support (financially as well as morally) from the State. But what we have is-- yes, the Misery of Culture. No word for this department of torture. It should be abolished. What a waste of taxpayers' money!

I sometimes feel that

I sometimes feel that personal appreciation of literature is one thing and teaching it is another. How can one reconcile these two? Or does one automatically lead to theother.

Joy, I'm not quite sure what

Joy, I'm not quite sure what you mean. The problem could stem from the fact that while the meaning of 'appreciation ' is 'evaluation, critical analysis', it has come to have a second meaning: ' liking for'. When you speak of "personal appreciation of literature" I assume you are using the 2nd, more popular meaning. I'd be surprised if anyone teaching literature didn't have a personal enthusiasm for particular works & authors, and vice-versa. However, my understanding of the role of the teacher is that one should introduce students to a wide range of work, including stuff one isn't particularly fond of, & give them the basic tools for analysis & criticism. From then on it's up to the students to form their own tastes and opinions about what constitutes 'good' literature.

One of my supervisors, an old-style Cambridge liberal, once handed back a post-grad paper I'd written on a device used by Brecht with the comment, "I absolutely disagree with everything you've written, but you've argued it extremely well. I therefore have no alternative but to award you an 'A'." The department I was studying in had a rule that an 'A' could only be awarded if a 2nd opinion had been obtained from another senior member of staff, a process involving some extra trouble, so I was really impressed. From that moment I knew what kind of teacher I'd like to be, if I ever became an academic! I don't respect a lot of the newer academics who align themselves with one particular critical perspective & expect their students to ape their opinions. I tell my current Thai students to argue with me, & I sometimes set up situations where they have to. I know they were shocked at first, because they have been taught that this is 'disrespectful' within traditional Thai culture, but I think they are starting to have more understanding of the value of skepticism, and of their own opinions - also the necessity of backing these up with reason, which involves self-questioning.

BTW, I've just spent 4 days

BTW, I've just spent 4 days on a jungle mountain with 42 Thai visual artists who are also teachers of traditional & contemporary art & craft at a very fine art college. I've been the only foreigner participating in a project that they do, connecting conservation with art, for 5+ years. Part of this year's project involved working in 2 tribal villages (not the tourist ones!), including workshops with school-kids & being taken on a trek, & taught, by a Karen 'Wise Man'. It was wonderful, & I'm full of admiration for these teacher-artists.

Magic Realism is a term which

Magic Realism is a term which was coined by a German art critic to describe a style of visual art in Germany in the 1920s. It began to be used to describe a genre of fiction writing in Latin America much later - around the 50s or early 60s. It is anachronistic & quite incorrect in a literary-critical sense to apply it to pre-realist writing. The 'realism' in it is a result of, & sometimes a comment on, the realist literary movement, which is characterised by depictions of mundane, 'ordinary' life, including its harsh realities, in detail . I have no problems with it being applied to the work of writers in other countries, even UK (e.g. Angela Carter). In fact it is now fairly widespread.

M: Didn't the whole realism

M: Didn't the whole realism thingy begin with modernism (modernity begun in late 18th C intellectual/artistic movement)? And did you not think Swift fit in magic realism genre? The point is the root of it (in a modern sense) is founded in Germany. But I guess it's just a matter of different framework; I start from philosophy, you from literary criticism- better put a break on this one otherwise I'll be on this thread forever. I have a Passion for literature and arts, less interest in unimaginative academism (BTW, your teacher could be an enemy of mine-- my training was a long blissful of indoctrination; thank god, I've found the light and switched side!). The art project you were involved sounds fabulous.

Joy: I personally think there's a connection between the love of literature and good teaching. Teachers with the heart of literature tend to be more thoughtful and more considerate to the development of their students. This tends to apply to teachers across disciplines. Once I observed a teacher-training class of physics. The class was led by a young English man who came to do a teacher-training certificate directly after he completed his undergraduate studies. This man was teaching upper secondary physics (grade 11). A lot of discussion in the class was about an introduction to String Theory (universe, time, space, blackhole, etc.). They were busy debating the notion of time when I watched on the day. Fast forward- fast forward- after an hour went, the teacher picked up a book called 'On Beauty' by Zadie Smith. Smith was a best-selling writer at the time; and it appeared that many students in the class like her. The young teacher, who himself graduated with first class honours in Physics, told the class that he found the best definition of time from the acknowledgement page of this book. Zadie Smith thanked her partner for letting her understand that "Time is how you spend your love". I don't think anyone can put it better than that. The class was in awe. Suddenly it became alive. I was deadly impressed with the teaching ability of this man.

Sub, but how abt when one has

Sub, but how abt when one has has very little chance/ no chance to choose one wants to teach, and has to teach the same thing over and over again, and students are tested the same thing over and over again and it seems certain answers are expected (although there are so many ways to read and interpret a literary work).
Sounds like i'm blaming the system too much. Certainly there must be a way for inpiring /creative teacher to handle all this. ..if you see no way out and keep on feeling increasingly bored with teaching, it probably means u are just not enthusiastic or talented enough for this job. changing to another job might be a good option, i think,

Joy, don't lose faith. Sure

Joy, don't lose faith. Sure you have much to offer to your students. You're now frustrating with the 'system' as it currently forbids you to bring out the best of you and the best of your students. The problem of Thai educational system is of cultural one - uneasy to amend in short time span, but personally, I don't want you to quit teaching. I'll come back to this. Stay put.
m- I'm not a fan of the French naturalist/realist school; though Flaubert's L'Éducation sentimentale is one of my all time favourites. A definition of time- 'Time is how you spend your love'; from a philosophical point of view, this isn't an anecdote, but reality. Love (with big L) is infinite. The man's brain knows Physics. His heart knows Infinity. This is Cosmo. Been to any concert at Mahidol College of Music? I heard the orchestra there has real potentials.

Sub and Michael, many thanks

Sub and Michael, many thanks for the encouragement. i in fact also have personal issues to deal as well with so it is not just the system --i'm not assertive or outspoken enough when dealing with fellow Thais, sometimes trying to please people at work too much in order to fit in /or not brave enough to be different (and thus losing principle/the gist of things along the way).

I think you're a bright young

I think you're a bright young thing- have ability to grasp innuendoes fast and probably have more modesty than most (don't know if this will do any good, I'm a bit dry at giving compliments). Don't worry too much about not fitting in with society, it isn't your fault. If a society or government is strong, it has to be the one who provides and ensures that there'd be room for the misfits to live happily. And I'd say that the misfits are likely to be the more talented and more creative ones. Any societies forbidding differences and diversities are killing their own talents- they're generally mushroomed with feeble minds and mutilated hearts.
I now have to help out a family member with her work - the sort of work in which neither of our hearts are so involved, but in the game of commercial success, we'd still have to do it- see, you're not alone. Best.

m- Cagian m (or is it Cagist?) ok. like your Understanding of anecdote. People laugh too much at things they don't really understand these days.

Thanks, Sub. No, I haven't

Thanks, Sub. No, I haven't been to Mahidol for a concert. I've been invited many times by both Thais & farang, but haven't been able to yet. Everyone tells me they're very good - I had an email from an Australian friend a couple of days ago, telling me about a recent concert, but I was having a John Cage experience on a mountain-top! It's on my list of undiscovered delights.

BTW, an anecdote is a story about something which actually happened, usually from the story-teller's experience.

Sub, Balzac et al (French,

Sub, Balzac et al (French, mid 19thC) are widely credited with getting literary realism going, but of course you're right in tracing its origins to late 18thC. No, I didn't say that I saw Swift fitting in to MR - quite the contrary. What I was getting at was that MR is a post-realist thing, and that it's addressed to people whose thought is the result of everything that has come after that time.

I really like your science teacher anecdote. Where was the class? I love the notion of eternity, rather than linear time. In my dream, the 18thC, e.g., is going on somewhere, right now. One of my ancestors (on both sides of my family!) was an early modernist writer, who confessed to 'eating' opium. If the scientists could just work out how to move through time, I could meet him...

Joy, having had to teach in a 'university' here where the exams were all by multiple-choice questions (marked by a machine, for god's sake!), & we were required to upgrade lazy students who should have failed, I can sympathise with your current situation. All I can say is, don't give up! Look around for a better position - but don't resign until you sign a new contract. Keep going, because it's clear that there will be big changes in education here over the next few years. Experienced & creative teachers with ideals & an understanding that 'education' is about much more than absorbing information & passing exams will be needed. Hold on to your enthusiasm. I find meditation a big help in re-charging my creative energy, when I'm dragged down by dull, ploddy bureaucratic thought (The Enemy!).

Thanks John! Please tell your

Thanks John!

Please tell your friends across the world to send a card to Da Torpido as well. We need cards from people across the world. This is to show that we are still concerning about Da's situation in the cell and we do not forget her and support her freedom of speech.

Thanks for Da again

To Prachatai: I'd like to

To Prachatai: I'd like to donate to Kittichai, but it's more convenient for me to pay via Paypal. Can Kittichai (or Palang Ruam Jai Group) set up a Paypal account for this cause-- will you be able to act as a go-between? Cheers.

Latest update on Da

Latest update on Da Torpedo:

Her request for temporary release (regarding her molar abscesses treatment) had been turned down by district court last Dec. The explanation for such refusal is, considering the seriousness of the offensive crimes she deliberately and repeatedly committed, and the condition of her illness was not considered life-threatening nor affected her normal daily-life in general.

Even the one convicted for first degree murder, should have been treated with respected at least on the basis of humanrights. Is the crime she committed more serious than murder? Is the alleged action she committed made herself something less than human?

In this country, one can not commit any crime more serious than this! So let's stand up and sing aloud (for your own sake).

The explanation for such

The explanation for such refusal is, considering the seriousness of the offensive crimes she deliberately and repeatedly committed...

It's clear that Da has offended powerful people. It is not at all clear that she committed any crimes at all. But how would we know when she was convicted in secret by kangaroo court? The fact that the closed the "trial" argues that they had nothing against her that would stand up in a real court. Bush/Cheney/Obama have done the same thing at Guantanamo. The real purpose of secret "trials" is to protect the accusers from being found out at having imprisoned people with no evidence of any real crime.

...and the condition of her illness was not considered life-threatening nor affected her normal daily-life in general.

And in addition to their self-asserted competence as lawyers and judges they are also medical doctors... of have the services of compliant doctors on tap, the sort who sell attestations of good health, patient unseen?

This is a hideous fraud. It is a black mark on the Thai soul that the "authorities" have been able to get away with this, just as it is a dreadful black mark on our American soul that we have sat on our hands for nine years while first Bush/Cheney and now Obama continue to roll out their serial aggressions against Islamic countries.

Post new comment

The content of this field is kept private and will not be shown publicly.
Comments are limited to a maximum of 2500 characters.
  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.
Image CAPTCHA
Enter the characters shown in the image.